Our rule of thumb is to enjoy your fudge within 14 days of it leaving our shop. (That is if you haven’t already devoured it by then!)

If you’re wanting to keep your fudge for longer than two weeks, wrap it up nice and tight and pop it in the freezer for up to three months. After a little thawing time, it’ll be good as gold.

Throughout the year, we have up to 21 different Mackinac Island fudge flavors on rotation (including vegan chocolate!).  All are handcrafted inside our traditional copper pots before gracing our marble slab. Ryba’s is always cooking up something new, from our 6 original flavors to holiday favorites, stop by regularly to see which flavors are currently available. Be sure to check out our Flavors page to explore all our offerings.

Sign up for 906 Rewards and follow us on Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter to receive the latest updates on seasonal flavors.

We use the traditional ingredients of sugar, milk, and butter when making most of our fudge flavors. (Our Vegan fudge does not contain any dairy.) For our chocolate flavors, we use chocolate that contains soy lecithin. We add nuts and other ingredients to create our menu of fudge flavors.

Every flavor of fudge, with the exception of Oreo, is gluten-free.

All of our fudge is made in-house in our Ryba’s shops, where we handle walnuts, pecans, cashews, and peanuts. While we take careful precautions to avoid any allergy contamination, we’re unable to guarantee that any flavor is completely free of traces of nuts.

If you expose fudge to too much air, it’ll start to dry out. But that doesn’t mean you can’t still enjoy it. Simply trim away the dried edges and the inside should still be creamy and delicious.

  • Birthdays
  • Corporate Gifting
    • For clients
    • For employees
    • Event Swag Bags
  • Holidays
    • Valentines Day
    • Easter
    • Halloween
    • Thanksgiving
    • Christmas / Hanukkah
  • Parties
    • Superbowl
    • Wedding Favors
  • Or ‘Just Because’ life is sweet

Our rich family history spills over into our unique recipes and out onto the marble slab. Ryba’s makes a superior fudge, offering superb flavor and a creamy texture. From our family to yours, it fills us with pride to share our legacy of Michigan-made handcrafted freshness in all of our offerings. Visit our online shop to see what sweet treats inspire you.

Absolutely! Ryba’s fudge and our other sweet treats make perfect gifts for any occasion. We can help you send corporate gifts to clients across the country or as a ‘just because’ to your aunt with the sweet tooth.

Our online shop supports shipping to a single or multiple locations. Personalization is also available at checkout, simply indicate it’s a gift and you’ll have the option to include a free message. We can even gift wrap it for a small fee.

We have special tools and quantity discounts available for corporate gift giving. Visit our Corporate Gifting page for more information.

We offer Mackinac Island Gift Cards in our online shop. Simply add it to your order and checkout as normal and we’ll send it to the shipping address you supply at checkout.

If your shipping address is within one of the 48 states of the contiguous US, we can ship our fudge to you. We process and ship every order within 24 hours of it being placed, Monday through Friday.

It’s important to us for your Ryba’s Mackinac Island fudge to arrive fresh and decadently delicious. Unfortunately, we’re unable to ship to Hawaii, Alaska, Canada, or anywhere else outside the contiguous United States since we can’t guarantee that it’ll arrive on your doorstep at the level of quality you deserve.

Currently, our online ordering system requires prepayment for any orders using a Mackinac Island Gift Card as payment. To make an online order using a gift card, enter the gift card number in the “906 Rewards Number” field at checkout and notify us in the “Order Notes” section that you’d like to redeem your Gift Card. Enter your credit card details as usual and place the order. After we’ve processed your order and applied your gift card balance, we will refund your credit card accordingly.

If you would rather not prepay for your gift card order, please contact us at info@ryba.com or 800.447.9227 and we’d be happy to help you redeem your gift card.

If you’re hoping for your fudge to arrive by a certain date, you can specify this in the “Order Notes” at checkout. If your delivery date is longer than three days from your order date, we may choose to delay the processing and shipment of your order so that your fudge and other sweet treats arrive as fresh as possible. Our online ordering system requires us to charge your credit card at the time of your order, even if the shipment is requested for a later date. But don’t worry, we’ll process your order accordingly and have your delicious fudge headed your way when you want it.

Nope! All of our fudge is made by hand and carefully packed after being thoroughly cooked. This ensures that your fudge will stay nice and smooth (and solid), even when shipping it to warmer locales.

The exception to this is our Vegan fudge. In the warmer months, due to its lower melting temperature, we are very conscientious of Vegan fudge shipping availability. We do offer it in limited edition batches throughout the year and it is readily available in the cooler months. Be sure to sign up for 906 Rewards to receive email notifications of when it’ll be available for shipment.

After you’ve placed your order, you’ll receive an order confirmation email, which means we’re busy getting everything ready to ship. Once we’ve sent your package on its way, we’ll send you a second shipping confirmation email which includes a USPS tracking number. Click the tracking number link in that email to check your expected delivery date or to track the shipment progress.

Here at Ryba’s we love the holidays. Gathering with family and friends, eating good food, watching football, getting outside… the list goes on. Our favorite fudge and sweet treats are the perfect addition to any holiday gathering. Not to mention, they always seem to top the list for ‘favorite gift received.’

Like everyone else, we expect the holiday shipping season to be busy. So, in order to get you your holiday goodies, please give yourself (and us!) some extra time. A good rule of thumb is 10 days, just to be sure.

Have you signed up for 906 Rewards? Once you do, you’ll receive all the latest news from Ryba’s including upcoming holiday specials, limited edition batch flavors, contests, giveaways, and more. And don’t forget to follow us on Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter!

Though we love our nearby neighbors to the north, the whole international shipping/customs thing sure puts a wrench in any possible fudge supply chain. Long delivery times and border delays don’t mesh well with our perishable products. So instead, we’ll just have to wait until we get to see our Canadian friends in person on the Island.

Sign up for 906 Rewards to receive the latest news from Ryba’s including holiday specials, limited edition batch flavors, contests, giveaways, and more. Also be sure to follow us on Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter!


Earn 906 Rewards [add link] on your Ryba’s purchase by entering your membership number (which is the phone number you used to register) in the “906 Rewards Number” field at checkout. (Or click the “sign up for free” link to join.) Our team will process your rewards and add them to your account.


To redeem 906 Rewards, please contact us at info@ryba.com or 800.447.9227 to process your order. Or for online orders, our system requires a prepayment. Please include your 906 Rewards Number in the applicable field at checkout AND notify us in the “Order Notes” section that you’d like to redeem your 906 Rewards. Enter your credit card details as usual and place the order. After we’ve processed your order and applied your rewards balance, we will refund your credit card accordingly.

Because who doesn’t like to save a little money? 906 Rewards is Mackinac Island’s biggest rewards program. It’s free to join and will have you earning and redeeming rewards while you shop, dine, and stay.

Earn spend-as-cash rewards on qualifying purchases at our family’s Island businesses including: 1852 Grill Room | Ice House BBQ | Island House Bike Rentals | Island House Hotel | Mary’s Bistro Draught House | Pancake House | Ryba’s Fudge Shops | Seabiscuit Cafe | Starbucks Mackinac Island

At Ryba’s Fudge Shops, our standards are impeccably high. If there is an occasion when you’re dissatisfied with your fudge, please contact us right away at info@ryba.com or 800.447.9227. If it doesn’t live up to our quality standards for freshness, taste, and texture, we’ll gladly help replace it.

At Ryba’s, we treat every customer like family. That means your privacy is extremely important to us. By placing an order on our site, you agree to be added to our 906 Rewards Club email list, which we use only to promote our family’s businesses. (You may unsubscribe from these at any time.)

All of the information collected on this site will be kept confidential and will not be sold, disclosed to third parties, or reused without your permission. Read our full Privacy Policy.